Climate
The key questions
Where they part ways, and how each answer holds up. An answer stands or falls on what it explains and how it survives criticism, not on who holds it.
A tint shows how one school of thought would answer these questions. The two views stay as they are.
-
What is the main cause of warming since the mid-20th century: human greenhouse gases, or the sun and natural cycles?
Mainstream: Human greenhouse gas emissions are the main cause, and natural solar, volcanic and ocean cycles cannot account for the warming.
Alternative: The sun, working through cosmic ray effects on clouds, plus natural oscillations and recovery from the Little Ice Age, drives most of the warming.
The mainstream answer holds up better, for now. The alternative cannot explain why temperatures kept rising while solar output fell, why the stratosphere cooled, or where the extra heat came from.
How each answer holds up
What it explains
Mainstream: It explains warming of the lower atmosphere together with cooling of the stratosphere, the pattern of warming at night and in winter, ocean heat gain, and an energy imbalance measured from space.
Alternative: It accounts for past correlations between solar activity and temperature, and for earlier natural warm and cool periods.
What would prove it wrong
Mainstream: The answer fails if the sun's output or cosmic ray flux rose in step with temperature, or if the stratosphere warmed along with the surface. Since about 1985, solar output has been flat or falling while temperatures rose, and the stratosphere has cooled. The answer has held up.
Alternative: The answer fails if temperature keeps rising while solar activity and cosmic ray flux stay flat or move the wrong way, and if lab and atmospheric studies show cosmic rays add little to cloud seeding. Both have been observed. The CLOUD experiment at CERN found the effect too weak, and the sun has declined since the 1980s while temperatures rose.
Weak spot
Mainstream: Attributing a precise share of warming depends on model estimates of aerosol cooling and internal variability. Models also run too hot in some regions and in some recent periods, so the exact numbers remain uncertain.
Alternative: 'Recovery' from the Little Ice Age names no energy source. The oscillations redistribute heat but cannot add it, and the ocean and the whole climate system are gaining energy. These views also do not explain stratospheric cooling, which points to greenhouse gases rather than the sun.
-
Is climate sensitivity low because of a stabilizing negative feedback from tropical clouds (the iris effect)?
Mainstream: Net cloud feedback is about neutral to positive, so sensitivity is moderate to high, with a likely range of roughly 2.5 to 4 °C per CO2 doubling.
Alternative: Cirrus cloud cover shrinks as the tropics warm, letting extra heat escape, so sensitivity is far lower than models say.
The mainstream answer holds up better, for now. The iris effect has been tested and found far weaker than proposed, and a low sensitivity conflicts with the paleoclimate record, which the mainstream range matches.
How each answer holds up
What it explains
Mainstream: It matches several independent lines of evidence: the paleoclimate record, warming observed over the instrumental period, and process studies of clouds and water vapor.
Alternative: It would account for slower-than-projected warming if the feedback were strong, and it explains why the climate would be stable.
What would prove it wrong
Mainstream: The answer fails if observed warming and energy balance consistently point to sensitivity well below the range, or if satellites show a strong net cloud cooling response to warming. Satellite studies have found a much weaker iris effect than proposed, and the paleoclimate and process evidence agree with the range.
Alternative: The answer fails if observed tropical cirrus does not shrink with warming enough to cancel the greenhouse effect, or if the sensitivity derived from the record stays well above the low estimate. Follow-up satellite studies found a much smaller effect, and some found a positive feedback.
Weak spot
Mainstream: The range is still wide, and low-cloud feedback is hard to pin down. Some recent models with high sensitivity fit past climate poorly, so the upper end is not firmly settled.
Alternative: The size of the effect was tuned to fit data, and it was later found to be much weaker than first claimed. It also cannot explain the large warming and ice-age swings in the paleoclimate record, which require a high sensitivity.
-
Should the main policy response be rapid emissions cuts, or wealth creation and adaptation?
Mainstream: Cut emissions rapidly to net zero, with adaptation alongside, because of the risks of harm that is irreversible and unevenly distributed.
Alternative: Prioritize economic growth, innovation and adaptation, because wealthier societies suffer far fewer climate deaths and the costs of rapid cuts fall on the poor.
Still open. The answer depends on future damage versus the cost of cutting emissions, which will become clear as warming continues and clean energy costs keep falling.
How each answer holds up
What it explains
Mainstream: It addresses the cause of warming, and it addresses tipping-point and long-lived-CO2 risks that adaptation cannot reverse.
Alternative: It explains the large fall in disaster deaths as countries grow richer, and it points to the risks of costly energy for the poor.
What would show it failing
Mainstream: The policy fails if emissions keep rising despite the policies, or if mitigation costs far exceed the avoided damage. Renewables costs have fallen sharply, which helps it, but global emissions have not yet fallen enough, so success is unproven.
Alternative: The policy fails if damage to places that cannot adapt, such as heat extremes, sea-level rise and crop losses, grows faster than wealth and technology can offset. That would show adaptation falling short. The question is still open and depends on warming going forward.
Weak spot
Mainstream: It depends on coordinated global action, and the benefits of mitigation go to others. Emissions are still near record highs, and some damage estimates behind the cost-benefit case vary widely.
Alternative: The past decline in deaths came at modest warming, so it may not carry over to much higher warming. It also treats the damages as limited without addressing irreversible losses, such as ice sheets and coral reefs.
-
Is current warming unusual compared with the last thousand years?
Mainstream: Current global temperature is higher than at any time in the last several thousand years, and the pace of warming is exceptional.
Alternative: Present temperatures are not anomalous, because the Medieval Warm Period and similar periods were as warm.
The mainstream answer holds up better, for now. Global proxy reconstructions show medieval warmth was patchy and below today's global level, which the alternative cannot match with global evidence.
How each answer holds up
What it explains
Mainstream: It matches multiple proxy records such as tree rings, ice cores, corals and sediments, and the pace of warming compared with past change.
Alternative: It explains historical records of warm conditions in places such as the North Atlantic and Europe.
What would prove it wrong
Mainstream: The answer fails if proxy reconstructions show a global medieval warmth equal to today's, which has not been found. Medieval warmth was regional and uneven.
Alternative: The answer fails if global reconstructions show medieval warmth was not synchronous or as high as now. Multiple global reconstructions show that.
Weak spot
Mainstream: Proxy reconstructions have uncertainties and sparse coverage in the early centuries, particularly in the Southern Hemisphere.
Alternative: The evidence for medieval warmth is regional and does not show a global peak. The view also does not explain why the current rapid rise tracks the CO2 increase.
Where they agree
- Climate is the long-term statistical pattern of weather, usually averaged over about 30 years.
- Greenhouse gases trap heat, and CO2 in the atmosphere has risen since the Industrial Revolution.
- Earth's climate has changed naturally in the past, and the sun, clouds and ocean cycles affect it.
- Climate sensitivity (warming per doubling of CO2) and cloud feedbacks are real, important quantities that science must pin down.
Your verdict
Your badge
Read both sides to the end and earn a badge to share. Most people never open the other one.
- Mainstream
- Alternative
References
- Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). (2021). Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report.
- World Meteorological Organization (WMO). (2021). WMO Guidelines on the Calculation of Climate Normals (WMO-No. 1203).
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2020). Advancing the Science of Climate Change. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
- NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS). (2023). Global Temperature Data Records and Analysis Methods.
- Peixoto, J. P., & Oort, A. H. (1992). Physics of Climate. American Institute of Physics.
- Climate - Wikipedia
- Climate - World Meteorological Organization
Want to take notes?
Create an account to take notes on any argument, follow topics, save your searches and download your results as a PDF.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!